嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈��
響慕片 卦指云慕朕村 紗秘慕禰 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 〆辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂〇

the lumley autograph(測銚跡返治)-及4何蛍

酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何! 泌惚云慕短嗤堋響頼���誅卒亮茂�俊彭堋響��辛聞喘貧圭 "辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂" 孔嬬 才 "紗秘慕禰" 孔嬬��


     ;But what a queer old box this is�察�H´�察─�said Major D´�察�eyeing the 

trunk through his glass。 

     ;It's   one   I've   had   these  hundred   years�察─  �replied   the   colonel。   ;So   you 

think this trumpery will do�察�D´�拭─�

     ;Do�拭�To be sure it will�察�my dear fellowit gives your Milesian skin the 

true Nawaub dye。 But I was just trying to make out an old letter pasted in 

the lid   of   your   trunk�察  �under   my  nose   here。   Is   this   the   way   you   preserve 



                                               11 


´ Page 12´

                                   THE LUMLEY AUTOGRAPH 



your family archives�拭─�

     ��Milesian   =   slang   term   for   Irish�察  �from   Milesius�察  �mythical   Spanish 

conqueror of Ireland�察�Nawaub = from Nabob�察�Anglo´Indian slang for one 

who has returned home from India with a large fortune�� 

     ;That letter is really a curiosity in its way�察─�said the colonel�察�turning 

from the glass and relating its history�察�so far at least as it was known to 

himself。 

     His friend spelt it through。 

     ;My dear fellow�察�why don't you give this letter to the father of   your 

fair Louisa�察�he's quite rabid on such points�察�you'll make him a friend for 

life by it� ─�

     The advice was followed。 The letter was cut from its old position in 

the   lid   of   the   trunk�察  �and   presented   to   Sir   John   Blank�察  �the   father   of   the 

lovely Louisa�察�who�察�in his turn�察�soon placed the hand of his daughter in 

that of Colonel H´。 

     Sir   John�察  �a   noted   follower   in   the   steps   of   Horace   Walpole�察  �had   no 

sooner become the owner of this interesting letter�察�than he set to work to 

find out its origin�察�and to fill up its history。 Unfortunately�察�the sheet had 

received   some   wounds   in   the   wars�察  �as   well   as   the   gallant   colonel。   One 

corner   had   been   carried   away   by   an   unlucky   thrust   from   a   razornot   a 

sword�察  �while   the date   and signature had   also been   half   eaten   out   by  the 

white   ants   of   Bengal。   But   such   difficulties   as   these   were   only   pleasing 

obstacles in the way of antiquarian activity。 Sir John had soon formed an 

hypothesis perfectly satisfactory to himself。 His mother's name was Butler�察�

and he claimed some sort of affinity with the author of Hudibras�察�as the 

Christian name of the poor poet had been almost entirely devoured by the 

ants�察   �while    the   surname      had   also   suffered     here   and    there�察  �Sir   John 

ingeniously       pursuaded      ��sic��    himself    that   what    remained      had    clearly 

belonged       to  the   signature     of   the  great    satirist�察 �as   for   the  date�察   �the 

abbreviation   of   ;Nov。   20th。;   and   the   figures   16   marking   the   century�察�

were really tolerably distinct。 Accordingly�察�Sir John wrote a brief notice of 

Butler's   Life�察  �dwelling   much   upon   his   well´known   poverty�察  �and   quoting 

his epitaph�察�with the allusion to his indigence underscored�察 �lest he who 

living   wanted   all   things�察  �should�察  �when   dead�察  �want   a   tomb�察─  �and   placed 



                                                  12 


´ Page 13´

                                  THE LUMLEY AUTOGRAPH 



these remarks opposite the letter of our starving poet�察�which was registered 

in   the   volume   in   conspicuous   characters   as   an   ;Autograph   of   Samuel 

Butler�察�author of Hudibras�察�showing to what distress he was at one time 

reduced。; 

     ��Samuel       Butler    ��1612´1680���察      �another     English     author    popularly 

believed to have died in great poverty�察�he is best known for his long satiric 

mock´epic poem�察 �Hudibras; ��1663´1678���� 

     Here the sheet remained several years�察�until at length it chanced that 

Sir John's volume of autographs was placed in the hands of a gentleman 

who had recently read Mr。 Lumley's MS。 Life of Otway。 The identity of 

this letter�察�with that copied by Mr。 Lumley�察�immediately suggested itself�察�

and now the first sparks of controversy between the Otwaysians and the 

Butlerites were struck in Sir John's library。 〃From thence they soon spread 

to   the   four   winds   of   heaven�察  �falling   on   combustible   materials   wherever 

they lighted on a literary head�察�or collecting hands。 

     By the bye�察�the rapidity with which this collecting class has increased 

of late years is really alarming�察�who can foresee the state of things likely 

to exist in the next century�察�should matters go on at the same rate�拭�Reflect 

for a moment on the probable condition of distinguished authors�察�lions of 

the   loudest    roar�察  �if  the  number   of   autograph´hunters   were       to  increase 

beyond   what   it   is   at   present。   Is   it   not   to   be   feared   that   they   will   yet 

exterminate the whole race�察�that the great lion literary�察�like the mastodon�察�

will become extinct�拭�Or�察�perhaps�察�by taming him down to a mere producer 

of autographs�察�his habits will change so entirely that he will no longer be 

the same animal�察�no longer bear a comparison with the lion of the past。 On 

the other hand should the great race become extinct�察�what will be the fate 

of the family of autograph´feeders�拭�What a fearful state of things would 

ensue�察  �even   in   our  day�察  �were   the   supply  to   be   reduced   but   a   quire�  �The 

heart   sickens   at   the   picture   which   would   then   be   presentedcollectors 

turning on each other�察�waging a fierce war over every autographic scrap�察�

making a battle´field of every social circle。 Happily�察�nature seems always 

to keep up the balance in such matters�察�and it is a consoling reflection that 

if   the   million   are   now   consumers�察  �so   have   they   become   producers   of 

autographs�察�it is therefore probable that the evil will work its own remedy�察�



                                                13 


´ Page 14´

                                   THE LUMLEY AUTOGRAPH 



and we may hope that the great writers of the next century will be shielded 

in some measure by the diversion made in their favor through the lighter 

troops of the lion corps。 

     As   for   the   full   merits   of   the   controversy   so   hotly   waged   over   the 

Lumley autograph between the Otwaysians and the Butlerites�察�dividing the 

collecting world into two rival parties�察�we shall not here enter into it。 In all 

such matters it is better to go at once to the fountain head�察�if the reader is 

curious   on   the   subject�察  �as   doubtless   he   must   be�察  �he   is   referred   to   one 

octavo and five duodecimo volumes�察�with fifty pamphlets which have left 

little to say on the point。 Let it not be supposed�察�however�察�for an instant�察�

that the  writer of this   article is   himself undecided   in   his opinion   on  this 

question。  By  no   means�察  �and   he   hastens   to   repel   the  unjust suspicion�察 �by 

declaring   himself   one   of   the   warmest   Otwaysians。   It   is   true   that   he   has 

some private grounds for believing that a dispassionate inquiry might lead 

one to doubt whether Otway or Butler ever saw the Lumley autograph�察�but 

what of that�察�who has time or inclination for dispassionate investigation in 

these stirring days� �In the present age of universal enlightenment�察�we don't 

trouble ourselves to make up our opinionswe take and give them�察�we beg�察�

borrow�察�and steal them。 True�察�there are controversies involving matters so 

important in their consequences�察�so serious in their nature�察�that one might 

conceive either indifference or fanaticism equally inexcusable with regard 

to them�察�but there are also a thousand other subjects of discussion�察�at the 

present     day�察  �of   that   peculiar    character     which    can    only   thrive    when 

supported by passion and prejudice�察�and falling in with a dispute of this 

nature�察    �it  is  absolutely     necessary      to  jump     at  once     into   fanaticism。 

Accordingly�察      �I  had   no   sooner    obtained     a  glimpse    of   the  letter  of   the 

starving   poet�察  �embalmed   within   the   precious   leaves   of   one   of   the   most 

noted     albums      of   Europe�察    �than    I  immediately       enlisted     under    Lady 

Holberton's colors as a faithful Otwaysian。 With that excellent lady I take 

a tragical view of the Lumley Letter�察�conceiving that a man must be blind 

as a bat�察�not to see that it was written by the author of Venice Preserved�察�

and this in spite of other celebrated collectors�察�who find in the same sheet 

so   much   that   is   comical   and   Hudibrastic。   Strange   that   any   man   in   his 

senses   should   hold   such   an   opinionyet   the   Butlerites   number   strong�察�



                                                 14 


´ Page 15´

                                   THE LUMLEY AUTOGRAPH 



some of them are respectable people�察�too�察�more's the pity that 
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何!
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��