嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈��
響慕片 卦指云慕朕村 紗秘慕禰 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 〆辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂〇

the ways of men(繁断議返粁)-及27何蛍

酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何! 泌惚云慕短嗤堋響頼���誅卒亮茂�俊彭堋響��辛聞喘貧圭 "辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂" 孔嬬 才 "紗秘慕禰" 孔嬬��


handling。 The habit of taking liberties with young relations is a common 

form of a relaxed social code and the besetting sin of elderly people�察�who�察�

having little to interest them in their own lives�察�imagine that their mission 

is to reform the ways and manners of their family。 Ensconced behind the 

respect which the young are supposed to pay them�察�they give free vent to 

inclination�察  �and   carp�察  �cavil�察  �and   correct。   The   victims   may   have   reached 

maturity  or   even   middle   age�察  �but   remain   always   children to   these   social 

policemen�察�to be reproved and instructed in and out of season。 ;I am doing 

this   for   your   own   good�察─  �is   an   excuse   that   apparently  frees   the   veterans 

from the necessity of respecting the prejudices and feelings of their pupils�察�

and lends a gloss of unselfishness to actions which are simply impertinent。 

Oddly enough�察�amateur ;schoolmarms; who fall into this unpleasant habit 

are     generally     oversensitive�察     �and    resent     as   a   personal     affront    any 

restlessness under criticism on the part of their victims。 It is easy�察�once the 

habit is acquired�察�to carry the suavity and consideration of general society 

into   the   home   circle�察  �yet   how   often   is   it   done�拭  �I   should   like   to   see   the 

principle that ordered presentation of arms to the infant princess applied to 

our     intimate    relations�察   �and    the   rights    of   the   young     and    dependent 

scrupulously respected。 

     In the third act of CASTE�察�when old Eccles steals the ;coral; from his 



                                               94 


´ Page 95´

                                     THE WAYS OF MEN 



grandson's   neck�察  �he   excuses   the   theft   by   a   grandiloquent   soliloquy�察  �and 

persuades      himself     that  he   is  protecting     ;the   weak    and   the   humble; 

��pointing to himself�� ;against the powerful and the strong; ��pointing to the 

baby��。 Alas�察�too many of us take liberties with those whom we do not fear�察�

and   excuse   our   little   acts   of   cowardice   with   arguments   as   fallacious   as 

those of drunken old Eccles。 



                                              95 


´ Page 96´

                                    THE WAYS OF MEN 



          CHAPTER 18 ´ What is ;Art;�拭�



       IN   former   years�察  �we   inquiring   youngsters   in   foreign   studios   were 

much     bewildered      by   the  repetition   of   a  certain   phrase。   Discussion     of 

almost any picture or statue was ��after other forms of criticism had been 

exhausted�� pretty sure to conclude with�察 �It's all very well in its way�察�but 

it's  not   Art。;   Not    only   foolish    youths    but   the  ;masters;     themselves 

constantly  advanced   this   opinion   to   crush   a   rival   or   belittle   a   friend。  To 

ardent minds seeking for the light and catching at every thread that might 

serve   as   a   guide   out   of   perplexity�察  �this   vague   assertion   was   confusing。 

According   to   one   master�察  �the   eighteenth´century   ;school;   did   not   exist。 

What had been produced at that time was pleasing enough to the eye�察�but 

;was   not Art� ─  �In   the   opinion   of   another�察  �Italian   music   might   amuse   or 

cheer the ignorant�察�but could not be recognized by serious musicians。 

     As most of us were living far from home and friends for the purpose of 

acquiring      the  rudiments     of   art�察 �this  continual    sweeping     away    of   our 

foundations   was   discouraging。   What   was   the   use�察  �we   sometimes   asked 

ourselves�察�of toiling�察�if our work was to be cast contemptuously aside by 

the   next   ;school;     as  a  pleasing    trifle�察 �not  for  a  moment      to  be  taken 

seriously�拭�How was one to find out the truth�拭�Who was to decide when 

doctors disagreed�拭�Where was the rock on which an earnest student might 

lay   his   cornerstone   without   the   misgiving   that   the   next   wave   in   public 

opinion would sap its base and cast him and his ideals out again at sea�拭�

     The    eighteenth´century       artists  and   the   Italian  composers      had   been 

sincere and convinced that they were producing works of art。 In our own 

day the idol of one moment becomes the jest of the next。 Was there�察�then�察�

no fixed law�拭�

     The short period�察�for instance�察�between 1875 and the present time has 

been   long   enough   for   the   talent   of   one   painter   ��Bastien´Lepage��   to   be 

discovered�察  �discussed�察  �lauded�察  �acclaimed�察        �then   gradually   forgotten     and 

decried。   During   the   years   when   we   were   studying   in   Paris�察  �that   young 

painter's works were pronounced by the critics and their following to be 

the last development of Art。 Museums and amateurs vied with each other 

in acquiring his canvases。 Yet�察�only this spring�察�while dining with two or 



                                             96 


´ Page 97´

                                      THE WAYS OF MEN 



three   art   critics   in   the   French   capital�察  �I   heard   Lepage's   name   mentioned 

and his works recalled with the smile that is accorded to those who have 

hoodwinked the public and passed off spurious material as the real thing。 

     If any one doubts the fleeting nature of a reputation�察�let him go to a 

sale   of   modern   pictures   and   note   the   prices   brought   by   the   favorites   of 

twenty years ago。 The paintings of that arch´priest�察�Meissonier�察�no longer 

command   the   sums   that   eager   collectors   paid   for   them   a   score   of   years 

back。 When a great European critic dares assert�察�as one has recently�察�of the 

master's   ;1815�察─  �that   ;everything   in   the   picture   appears   metallic�察  �except 

the   cannon   and   the   men's   helmets�察─  �the   mighty   are   indeed   fallen�   �It   is 

much   the   same   thing   with   the   old   masters。 There   have   been   fashions   in 

them as in other forms of art。 Fifty years ago Rembrandt's work brought 

but   small   prices�察  �and   until   Henri   Rochefort   ��during   his   exile��   began   to 

write up the English school�察�Romneys�察�Lawrences�察�and Gainsboroughs had 

little market value。 

     The result is that most of us are as far away from the solution of that 

vexed     question     ;What     is  Art�拭─   �at  forty   as  we    were   when     boys。    The 

majority   have   arranged   a   compromise   with   their   consciences。   We   have 

found out what we like ��in itself no mean achievement���察�and beyond such 

personal      preference�察    �are  shy    of  asserting    ��as   we   were    fond    of  doing 

formerly��   that   such   and   such   works   are   ;Art�察─  �and   such   others�察  �while 

pleasing and popular�察�lack the requisite qualities。 

     To   enquiring   minds�察  �sure   that   an   answer   to   this   question   exists�察  �but 

uncertain   where   to   look   for   it�察  �the   fact   that   one   of   the   thinkers   of   the 

century has�察�in a recent ;Evangel�察─�given to the world a definition of ;Art�察─�

the result of many years' meditation�察�will be received with joy。 ;Art�察─�says 

Tolstoi�察 �is simply a condition of life。 It is any form of expression that a 

human being employs to communicate an emotion he has experienced to a 

fellow´mortal。; 

     An author who�察�in telling his hopes and sorrows�察�amuses or saddens a 

reader�察�has in just so much produced a work of art。 A lover who�察�by the 

sincerity of his accent�察�communicates the flame that is consuming him to 

the object of his adoration�察�the shopkeeper who inspires a purchaser with 

his   own   admiration   for   an   object   on   sale�察  �the   baby   that   makes   its   joy 



                                               97 


´ Page 98´

                                      THE WAYS OF MEN 



known       to  a  parent    ´  artists�   �artists�  �Brown�察     �Jones�察  �or   Robinson�察     �the 

moment       he   has   consciously   produced         on   a  neighbor's     ear  or   eye   the 

sensation that a sound or a combination of colors has effected on his own 

organs�察�is an artist� �

     Of   course   much   of   this   has   been   recognized   through   all   time。   The 

formula   in   which   Tolstoi   has   presented   his   meditations   to   the   world   is�察�

however�察�so fresh that it comes like a revelation�察�with the additional merit 

of   being   understood�察  �with   little   or   no   mental   effort�察  �by  either  the   casual 

reader�察  �who�察  �with   half´attention   attracted   by  a   headline�察  �says   to   himself�察�

;`What is art��' That looks interesting� ─�and skims lightly down the lines�察�

or   the   thinker   who�察  �after   perusing   Tolstoi's   lucid   words�察  �lays   down   the 

volume with a sigh�察�and murmurs in his humiliation�察 �Why have I been all 

these years seeking in the clouds for what w
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何!
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��