嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈��
響慕片 卦指云慕朕村 紗秘慕禰 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 〆辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂〇

three dialogues-及13何蛍

酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何! 泌惚云慕短嗤堋響頼���誅卒亮茂�俊彭堋響��辛聞喘貧圭 "辺茄欺厘議箝誓匂" 孔嬬 才 "紗秘慕禰" 孔嬬��


     。 It doth not readily occur what I can answer you。

     。 But�察�methinks you should be ready to own the truth��
when it has been fairly proved to you。 We indeed�察�who are beings
of finite powers�察�are forced to make use of instruments。 And the
use of an instrument sheweth the agent to be limited by rules of
another's prescription�察�and that he cannot obtain his end but in
such a way�察�and by such conditions。 Whence it seems a clear
consequence�察�that the supreme unlimited agent useth no tool or
instrument at all。 The will of an Omnipotent Spirit is no sooner
exerted than executed�察�without the application of means�察�which��
if they are employed by inferior agents�察�it is not upon account
of any real efficacy that is in them�察�or necessary aptitude to
produce any effect�察�but merely in compliance with the laws of
nature�察�or those conditions prescribed to them by the First
Cause�察�who is Himself above all limitation or prescription
whatsoever。

     。 I will no longer maintain that Matter is an
instrument。 However�察�I would not be understood to give up its
existence neither�察�since�察�notwithstanding what hath been said�察�it
may still be an 。

     。 How many shapes is your Matter to take�拭�Or�察�how
often must it be proved not to exist�察�before you are content to
part with it�拭�But�察�to say no more of this ��though by all the laws
of disputation I may justly blame you for so frequently changing
the signification of the principal term��  I would fain know
what you mean by affirming that matter is an occasion�察�having
already denied it to be a cause。 And�察�when you have shewn in what
sense you understand �察�pray�察�in the next place�察�be
pleased to shew me what reason induceth you to believe there is
such an occasion of our ideas��

     。 As to the first point�此�by  I mean an
inactive ��220�� unthinking being�察�at the presence whereof God
excites ideas in our minds。

     。 And what may be the nature of that inactive
unthinking being��

     。 I know nothing of its nature。

     。 Proceed then to the second point�察�and assign some
reason why we should allow an existence to this inactive��
unthinking�察�unknown thing。

     。 When we see ideas produced in our minds�察�after an
orderly and constant manner�察�it is natural to think they have
some fixed and regular occasions�察�at the presence of which they
are excited。

     。 You acknowledge then God alone to be the cause of
our ideas�察�and that He causes them at the presence of those
occasions。

     。 That is my opinion。

     。 Those things which you say are present to God��
without doubt He perceives。

     。 Certainly�察�otherwise they could not be to Him an
occasion of acting。

     。 Not to insist now on your making sense of this
hypothesis�察�or answering all the puzzling questions and
difficulties it is liable to�此�I only ask whether the order and
regularity observable in the series of our ideas�察�or the course
of nature�察�be not sufficiently accounted for by the wisdom and
power of God�察�and whether it doth not derogate from those
attributes�察�to suppose He is influenced�察�directed�察�or put in
mind�察�when and what He is to act�察�by an unthinking substance��
And�察�lastly�察�whether�察�in case I granted all you contend for�察�it
would make anything to your purpose�察�it not being easy to
conceive how the external or absolute existence of an unthinking
substance�察�distinct from its being perceived�察�can be inferred
from my allowing that there are certain things perceived by the
mind of God�察�which are to Him the occasion of producing ideas in
us��

     。 I am perfectly at a loss what to think�察�this notion
of  seeming now altogether as groundless as the rest。

     。 Do you not at length perceive that in all these
different acceptations of �察�you have been only supposing
you know not what�察�for no manner of reason�察�and to no kind of
use��

     。 I freely own myself less fond of my notions since
they have been so accurately examined。 But still�察�methinks�察�I
have some confused perception that there is such a thing as
。 ��221��

     。 Either you perceive the being of Matter immediately
or mediately。 If immediately�察�pray inform me by which of the
senses you perceive it。 If mediately�察�let me know by what
reasoning it is inferred from those things which you perceive
immediately。 So much for the perception。 Then for the Matter
itself�察�I ask whether it is object�察。察�cause��
instrument�察�or occasion�拭�You have already pleaded for each of
these�察�shifting your notions�察�and making Matter to appear
sometimes in one shape�察�then in another。 And what you have
offered hath been disapproved and rejected by yourself。 If you
have anything new to advance I would gladly bear it。

     。 I think I have already offered all I had to say on
those heads。 I am at a loss what more to urge。

     。 And yet you are loath to part with your old
prejudice。 But�察�to make you quit it more easily�察�I desire that��
beside what has been hitherto suggested�察�you will farther
consider whether�察�upon。 supposition that Matter exists�察�you can
possibly conceive how you should be affected by it。 Or�察�supposing
it did not exist�察�whether it be not evident you might for all
that be affected with the same ideas you now are�察�and
consequently have the very same reasons to believe its existence
that you now can have。

     。 I acknowledge it is possible we might perceive all
things just as we do now�察�though there was no Matter in the
world�察�neither can I conceive�察�if there be Matter�察�how it should
produce' any idea in our minds。 And�察�I do farther grant you have
entirely satisfied me that it is impossible there should be such
a thing as matter in any of the foregoing acceptations。 But still
I cannot help supposing that there is  in some sense or
other。  do not indeed pretend to determine。

     。 I do not expect you should define exactly the nature
of that unknown being。 Only be pleased to tell me whether it is a
Substance�察�and if so�察�whether you can suppose a Substance without
accidents�察�or�察�in case you suppose it to have accidents or
qualities�察�I desire you will let me know what those qualities
are�察�at least what is meant by Matter's supporting them��

     。 We have already argued on those points。 I have no
more to say to them。 But�察�to prevent any farther questions�察�let
me tell you I at present understand by  neither substance
nor accident�察�thinking nor extended being�察�neither cause��
instrument�察�nor occasion�察�but Something entirely unknown��
distinct from all these。 ��222��

     。 It seems then you include in your present notion of
Matter nothing but the general abstract idea of 。

     。 Nothing else�察�save only that I super´add to this
general idea the negation of all those particular things��
qualities�察�or ideas�察�that I perceive�察�imagine�察�or in anywise
apprehend。

     。 Pray where do you suppose this unknown Matter to
exist��

     。 Oh Philonous� �now you think you have entangled me��
for�察�if I say it exists in place�察�then you will infer that it
exists in the mind�察�since it is agreed that place or extension
exists only in the mind。 But I am not ashamed to own my
ignorance。 I know not where it exists�察�only I am sure it exists
not in place。 There is a negative answer for you。 And you must
expect no other to all the questions you put for the future about
Matter。

     。 Since you will not tell me where it exists�察�be
pleased to inform me after what manner you suppose it to exist��
or what you mean by its ��

     。 It neither thinks nor acts�察�neither perceives nor is
perceived。

     。 But what is there positive in your abstracted notion
of its existence��

     。 Upon a nice observation�察�I do not find I have any
positive notion or meaning at all。 I tell you again�察�I am not
ashamed to own my ignorance。 I know not what is meant by its
�察�or how it exists。

     。 Continue�察�good Hylas�察�to act the same ingenuous
part�察�and tell me sincerely whether you can frame a distinct idea
of Entity in general�察�prescinded from and exclusive of all
thinking and corporeal beings�察�all particular things whatsoever。

     。 Hold�察�let me think a little  I profess�察�Philonous��
I do not find that I can。 At first glance�察�methought I had some
dilute and airy notion of Pure Entity in abstract�察�but�察�upon
closer attention�察�it hath quite vanished out of sight。 The more I
think on it�察�the more am I confirmed in my prudent resolution of
giving none but negative answers�察�and not pretending to the least
degree of any positive knowledge or conception of Matter�察�its
�察�its �察�its �察�or anything belonging to it。

     。 When�察�therefore�察�you speak of the existence of
Matter�察�you have not any notion in your mind��

     。 None at all。

     。 Pray tell me if the case stands not thus  At
first�察�from a belief of material substance�察�you would have it
that the ��223�� immediate objects existed without the mind�察�then
that they are archetypes�察�
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
酔楯荷恬: 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈 梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈 梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何!
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��